Blog  »

Ethics in the closing of a humanitarian project

Ethics in the closing of a humanitarian project
Text and photo: Bruno Abarca

In the first quarter of 2025, following the USAID funding freeze and the executive orders issued by the new US administration, hundreds of development cooperation and humanitarian aid projects came to an abrupt end. This sudden disruption has highlighted the vulnerability of people in need of humanitarian assistance for which funding is no longer available, but also the humanitarian system’s dependence on a handful of donors and the damage, perhaps irreparable, to the entire sector and its professionals.

At the same time, many voices have questioned how the closure of these projects was being done. What additional negative consequences can an unplanned closure, without an exit strategy prepared in advance, have? And in what way can ethics be ensured in the closure of a humanitarian project, even when it occurs unexpectedly?

Exit strategies at the closure of a humanitarian action project

The closure of a humanitarian project is, by definition, inevitable. After all, humanitarian action is also, by definition, temporary. Ideally, the main reason should always be that the humanitarian needs that triggered the response no longer exist. If the emergency is over, humanitarian assistance should no longer be necessary, or it should evolve into another form of support for long-term recovery and sustainable development. However, an international cooperation project may end for many other reasons, such as a sharp deterioration in security, a significant shrinking of the humanitarian space needed to operate with neutrality or independence, or simply the end of funding.

Ideally, all these circumstances should also be anticipated, so that an exit strategy can be developed to consider different approaches. One option is to gradually scale down activities, which in some cases may even allow them to be restarted later, at least for a certain period, if doing so becomes relevant or feasible again. Another option is to transfer the project to another actor that can continue the activities and services. It may also be possible to change the intervention methods and objectives to adapt to the new situation. In other cases, however, the project and its activities come to an abrupt end.

In all these cases, although the dynamics may differ, tensions and difficult ethical dilemmas can arise, both of which can be hard to resolve. Moreover, when the process is not properly planned or carefully considered, it can cause harm to the individuals, communities and organizations involved in or supported by the project, including staff and local partners.

Is it possible to responsibly close a humanitarian intervention?

The ethics of the temporary

The temporality of humanitarian action should not lead to myopia. Indeed, in all humanitarian action, attention must be paid to past circumstances (usually fraught with social injustices) and how these circumstances have shaped the current crisis and the ongoing humanitarian response. An indispensable ethical element is also to try to understand the consequences that present actions may have, and to anticipate potential harms that may occur as a result of the intervention or its termination. For this reason, this look to the future must seek, from the beginning of the action, and as far as possible, to achieve a certain sustainability and advance in equity. Finally, none of this is possible if from the outset there is no deep respect for collaborative and inclusive approaches that value local knowledge and capacities.

It is a priority to think with the community, for the community

It is not enough to look at the problem from an external technical view. The first thing must always be to know what is important for a community in the closing of a project:

  • The transparency of organizations regarding their intentions, timelines and processes. This may require meetings and consultations with the community, which may be impossible if the necessary communication channels had not been created beforehand.
  • Collaboration between humanitarian organizations and local leaders When these people have been focal points of communication between the organization and the rest of the community, they need to be supported in this role.
  • Community participation in the closure process. This may include closing ceremonies, participatory end-of-project evaluations, or community decision-making activities on the next steps in addressing lingering problems. Moreover, in many instances, circumstances also allow for the decision to close the project to be discussed and analyzed with the community, its representatives, and even local staff of collaborating organizations.
  • The possibility of sustaining project activities after the end of the project. Some of the activities can be continued from the community, without further external support from the organization that developed the previous project, if an agreement is reached and they are assisted in the preparations.
  • The continuity of the organization's communication and connection with the community. Communities value the efforts of organizations to monitor the long-term impact of completed projects, and to keep abreast of community needs, even when they have no clear possibility of helping to alleviate them.
  • Community justice and relations in the closure process. Many intra-community dynamics and relations can deteriorate if, at project closure, some groups benefit more than others or if divisions have been created between them.
  • Support for communities to be better prepared for future crises. Humanitarian organizations should seek to incorporate disaster risk reduction and management components into their responses that empower and enable local communities and organizations to prepare for future crises.

Closing a humanitarian project should start on day one

The implications of the ethical aspects of project closure should be considered from the very design and initiation of interventions. However, on many occasions, little attention is paid to the elements related to the termination of the action, or to contingency plans in case its continuity becomes unsustainable. All too often, these aspects are completed by copying and pasting poorly thought-out texts, at the stage of writing proposals for submission to donor calls for proposals. Moreover, this problem occurs even in contexts where the early termination of a project is a likely scenario. When these issues are not addressed in the design and planning phase, there is also a high likelihood that they will be put on the back burner during implementation, when the workload and rush are greatest.

Continuous evaluation of the progress of activities and their results during the implementation of a project also makes it possible to take measures that make closure more manageable and acceptable. This can avoid moving from an accelerated emergency implementation (because of a backlog in financial execution) to an abrupt halt in activities. A gradual reduction allows participating and assisted families and communities to anticipate how the change will affect them, and to prepare better and in a more progressive manner for the closure. It also helps to ensure respect for the dignity, welfare and labor rights of local staff who terminate their contracts. Other aspects such as the ethical and responsible management of data collected during the project cannot be improvised at the last minute either.

The lack of planning on how to do, in an ethical and responsible manner, the closure of humanitarian projects even for sudden causes, produces frustration and confusion. Depending on the circumstances, they can also damage the image, local reputation and trust generated by the humanitarian system and its organizations. In addition to this, in humanitarian contexts, a poorly planned closure increases the risk of violence and insecurity.

The way we close projects is a reflection of how much we care about people and their communities

For all these reasons, it is essential to consider the ethical implications of closing a project, even before it begins. Doing so not only helps to reduce the unintended harm caused by humanitarian action, but also shows that the humanitarian system and its actors genuinely care about the people and communities they work with. After all, this is what lies behind the humanitarian imperative to alleviate suffering, and what gives us the legitimacy to continue working wherever we are needed.

Blog

The blog posts on Salud Everywhere complement its content on humanitarian action and international cooperation, health in humanitarian crises, and career advice with news, opinions, and analysis.

External links

When you submit this form, you accept that your message will be processed in accordance with the privacy policy. The email address is optional and is only used to reply to you.

Scroll to Top